Nia singing Strange Fruit by Billie Holiday at age 4



Uploaded by: cgoldsmith
Video Description:
Nia singing at age 4. I am Nia's mom. I have had some folks not understand why Nia is singing this. Nia is a little girl who listens to every word in a song...reason why I do not let her listen to the profane music that is out there and why Nia listens to mostly the old school...she even sings with the Grammy Award winning 70s group Earth Wind and Fire. See it on my page at www.youtube.com/user/cgoldsmith
I am a big fan of old school jazz. I played Strange Fruit in the car when Nia was about 3 and had no idea that she would listen to the lyrics so intently. I mean, most adults do not understand the nuances and meaning of this song because it is not literal...it is sung in a poetic vein. Not to brag on my child, but she is very perseptive and asked what the song meant. I just stated to her that sometimes people do bad things to others for no reason and that you should always treat others as you would want to be treated. Then she wanted to know what blood on the trees meant because she thought that "trees drink water" and she keep saying to me "mommy, I know that it has to be more than that because this song sounds so sad".
Nia is a very deep child and I like to be honest with her about things without being overly explicit. On the other hand, Jewish people have ALWAYS taught their children about the Holocaust...why? because they NEVER want that type of genocide to happen EVER again to their people. I grew up with a lot of Jewish children and they were taught about that from DAY ONE...even in Hebrew School and they were shown the number brands on the arms of their grandparents and told about the gas chambers....etc. No one says anything negative about that...so why is it wrong in this case
Slavery and Jim Crow were also a type of genocide. It is not too different from the Holocaust. It was the Holocaust of Blacks in America. This is not something that should be forgotten by anyone...my daughter included. It is part of her history and the story should be told...or it will be repeated over and over again.
Nia really feels this song and sometimes cries for her forefathers and foremothers when she sings it. She sings it so that they will not have died in vein, but for the fact that we still remember their spirits and will keep them alive in our hearts.
Think about it, at least Nia is learning something...at least I do not have her listening to the masogenistic booty shaking music that is out today. The music she listens to has a message. Before you judge, just listen to the stuff she does on my page.
However, I will thank you for your concern. I have nothing but the utmost respect for you for doing that.
Please look at my whole site to see what Nia is really about. www.youtube.com/user/cgoldsmith
You will see her on stage with Earth Wind and Fire in Vegas and singing mostly old school songs. She even starred in Mary J Blige's commercial on there and has been on Japanese TV. I try to send a message to young kids through Nia's music as follows;
1. There is nothing wrong with listening to music that is positive and or tells about your history. You don't need to listen to all the nasty booty shaking music that is out there...and to listen to other genres of music(Nia sings Portuguese songs, old school R and B songs,old school rock songs, and jazz.
2. Learn an instrument (Nia plays piano on youtube)
3. Children should be just that...children.. You do not have to look "grown" to be successful. Just be who you are. (Nia acts and dresses like a kid. No make up, no grown up hair...just a kid
4. Get an education. It is "cool" to be smart. (Nia reads in Spanish and English (above video) on youtube.) Nia goes to a full Spanish Immersion school and is an A student in 1st grade. She is 6 now and got into elementary school early.
Now all of this got started because I put these videos on youtube to show my out of town relatives what Nia was up to. I had no idea that she would get up to this day 8 million total hits and become the interest of folks around the world. However, her education comes first, but I try to hone her extra-curricular interests as well. Who knows, she may not want to do this when she is older and may want to be a Molecular Biologist like me (her mother)
Lastly, I do respect the words you said. I do hope you understand my points as well. Have a wonderful day.


Tags for this video: Billie cgoldsmith dance Fruit girl Holiday Holliday Nia sing Strange

Find more videos in the "Entertainment" category
See more videos uploaded by cgoldsmith

Related Videos
Nia singing Ain't Really Love by Mary J. Blige age 4Nia singing Can't Hide Love by Earth Wind and Fire at age 4Billie Holiday - Fine and Mellow (1957)
nia-singing-aint-really-love-by-mary-j-blige-age-4.htmlnia-singing-aint-really-love-by-mary-j-blige-age-4.htmlnia-singing-aint-really-love-by-mary-j-blige-age-4.html
Nia starring in the Mary J Blige commercial 4 her new albumbillie holiday - lady sings the bluesNia singing Reasons by Earth, Wind and Fire at age 2
nia-singing-aint-really-love-by-mary-j-blige-age-4.htmlnia-singing-aint-really-love-by-mary-j-blige-age-4.htmlnia-singing-aint-really-love-by-mary-j-blige-age-4.html


Share This Video:       StumbleUpon       del.icio.us       Reddit       digg       Furl       Spurl       Simpy       YahooMyWeb


Comments for this video: Show || Hide
Comments for this video on YouTube
this is a shame. ... ( 1 month ago by cjw030288)
this is a shame. she's making a mockery of the song. the video should be condemned. this song is no joke. you young ppl just dont know better.
WOW you put a lot ... ( 1 month ago by SigneRobertson)
WOW you put a lot of info on this video... Like a legal document almost. I'm sorry you had to explain so much. I think people who don't like it can just leave her alone, not come here and say racist things or accuse you of being bad parents. She's obviously a very intelligent and focused child and I admire her.
strange fruit, a ... ( 1 month ago by caribb57)
strange fruit, a blcak man hanging from a tree..........not a pretty song but very americantrue.
you don't have to ... ( 1 month ago by caribb57)
you don't have to explain yourself, jews think they have a monopoly on pain, during WWII milliosn died, not just jews, so there. you all can call me an antisemite now, I don't give a shit about that.
She is beautiful. ... ( 1 month ago by doldromofthemerry)
She is beautiful. Don't explain, don't explain.
WOW - when I first ... ( 1 month ago by piashantee)
WOW - when I first read the title I was like - "WHAT?! This lil baby is singin STRANGE FRUIT?!" - I can see why people are upset. It's a deep topic and people are emotionally connected to that song - that's one of those songs you listen to and you just go, "Damn.. that was ME/US/OUR she's singin about" and you wanna cry. But I feel you mom - kids listen to their parents music and if they get some history - more power. We. Will. NEVER. Forget. And I'm LOVIN the way you're raising her. Bless.
Thank you...well ... ( 1 month ago by cgoldsmith)
Thank you...well put...as in Billie's song "Don't Explain"
Thanks so much for ... ( 1 month ago by cgoldsmith)
Thanks so much for understanding. Please click on the "(more info") area of this video and you will see, in depth, why she sings this.
i so love her. ( 1 month ago by armondpb)
i so love her.
Wonderful little ... ( 1 month ago by Chikh8)
Wonderful little angel!
I am white but I ... ( 1 month ago by myogen2003)
I am white but I listened to black music like Ella Fitzgerald, Oscar Peterson, Modern Jazz Quartet and others when I was about three and was fascinated.
And now that I am 41 and listening to this little girl and knowing all I know and feel about jazz - you black guys are heavenly beings. In jazz you express something white people cannot express but we can hear it and feel it, at least I can. Thank you for your beautiful soul and all the great contribution to the human world.
sing little angel ... ( 1 month ago by elrebeco)
sing little angel sing keep up the good work this is some of the best music in the world mom and pops music later bopalina
Array ( 1 month ago by raimercerus)
hehe graciosita...
SEE YA...
Bravo baby girl!!!! ... ( 1 month ago by markdam)
Bravo baby girl!!!!! i cant think of a better song to cover! my daughter was wxposed to bille and ella very young and it has stuck with her now shes 21
Wow! Amazing how ... ( 3 weeks ago by travnm)
Wow! Amazing how much a child can sense. As a mother of a young daughter and wife of an American historian, it is important to know the past, especially the ugly parts. And our children must know this to continue the march to a more just society. The more we forget, more likely we are to repeat. The more jazz we can get to our children, the better! Look at what happened to Joshua Redman on the way to his law practice...you never know what the future holds. Sing on Nia!
She is so adorable, ... ( 3 weeks ago by daisyfuck)
She is so adorable, and listening to her sing along with the words gave me goosebumps. Her empathy and willingness to learn which you described in the description is so heart-warming and gives me hope for the future. :D
I commend you so ... ( 3 weeks ago by Aciremet)
I commend you so much! this is so amazing to me because there are old black people who've never heard this song ,let alone know it word for word! It has such meaning and its apart of our history as a people in this country. Kudos to Nia and Nia's mom!
it is quite ... ( 2 weeks ago by Jmanjuman)
it is quite interesting how she feels the music at such a young age, I forsee her doing great things in music once she's of age
wonderful to watch, ... ( 1 week ago by pheno09)
wonderful to watch, I wonder how she´ll feel, how her voice will change when she knows, what its about. Love her dress too lol
Sorry I just read ... ( 1 week ago by pheno09)
Sorry I just read the ´more info´´ bit. I congratulate you on educating ur daughter so and for her interest in the meaning and feelings behind the words. You have a wonderful daughter.
yeah, them jews, ... ( 1 week ago by greencoveredbridge)
yeah, them jews, lol! why don't they just get over it?
caribb57, yeah, ... ( 1 week ago by greencoveredbridge)
caribb57, yeah, them jews, lol, why don't they just get over it? lol
Your future ... ( 4 days ago by Timrose89)
Your future American Idol!!!!!
she is so cute i ... ( 2 days ago by flygirl630)
she is so cute i tell u



Tell a friend:


URL 
Embed Code